Trophy Wife 1×02 ‘Cold File’: The show’s new cast change is distracting


Trophy Wife is one of the newer network comedies that hasn’t found it’s stride yet. It’s been a mixed bag this fall for comedy, and a lot of these shows have a lot that needs working on. In comparison to it’s surprisingly entertaining pilot, this week’s episode of Trophy Wife feels particularly rigid. Which may be due to the noticeable casting change for Pete and Diane’s daughter, Hillary.

This isn’t an uncommon thing when a show starts, cast members get replaced or some characters only ever appear in the pilot (Coach from New Girl), but this episode isn’t enough to make the audience believe that this was the best decision. Having three stepchildren of different ages for Kate to tackle provided the possibility of a number of diverse and outrageous situations. However, with such a big age gap between the three it could have been distracting What made the pilot funny is the fact that Kate got drunk for Hillary, and this suggested that the show was going to explore more ridiculous situations teenage girls can get themselves into. Kate would have been a more lenient stepmother for Hillary and as she was open about her past experiences, she would have inadvertently been an influence on her teenage stepdaughter. The pilot Hillary was an angsty and disobedient early teen, where this new Hillary appears is a fairly innocent tween. At first the obvious casting change is really distracting, but it becomes more interesting as Hillary shares more screen time with her brother, Warren. The dynamic the two of them share is believable, but it’s their mother who is providing the amusement. Marcia Gay Harden continues to be the funniest character with her unconventional and terrifying parenting techniques. Watching her make the kids squirm and hearing her make remarks like “normal parents don’t get results” make the new casting change all worth while.


Source: ABC

The driving plot of this episode, and the show, is Kate’s struggle to fit in and feel like part of the family. It appears the show will focus on how she will try and fail to be an ordinary parent week after week. Whether she is wearing inappropriate clothes, or telling the kids stuff she shouldn’t, it’s pretty adamant that Kate is fairly clueless. Despite the fact that it’s extremely clear how Kate’s actions will backfire on her, she is a likeable character and you feel yourself wanting her to do well. Pete’s second ex-wife, Jackie, is less hostile towards Kate this week and it’ll be interesting to see if a friendship will blossom between the two. Diane is hilariously odd and ruthless, the show would really benefit from more scenes with her and Kate. Trophy Wife has an inventive premise, so hopefully the comedy will grow less awkward and more funnier.

is a filmmaker, cat lady, writer and general lover of TV who leaves her mark across the internet under the pseudonym Catstello. When she isn’t contributing to Sound on Sight, Portable and Gotta Watch It, she is posting top lists, reviews and other stuff on her own blog:

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google+ YouTube Vimeo 

Both comments and pings are currently closed.
  • Satan

    I disagree with pretty much everything you wrote. Plus it was hard to comprehend what you were attempting to point out, your composition is poorly constructed and was almost one big long run on sentence. How about some structure to your writing in the future? You basically had one paragraph that lead me to believe you had a different focus, and then the rest of your opinions were a part of a body and conclusion that was combined. Your blogging needs work, but I believe you can get that practice here and on facebook where it seems like everyone else is creating the same sub-standard articles and common gossipy opinionated crap. Good luck!

  • Jack Bisikirski

    The new Hilary had proven to be better then the Pilot Hilary.